• About This Blog

The Developing Outlook

~ www.marlonjohnson.com

Tag Archives: Stand Your Ground Law

On The State of Florida v George Zimmerman (2013): Part 2

Featured

Posted by marlonjohnson in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Florida, George Zimmerman, Hoodie, Justice, Sanford FL, Stand Your Ground Law, Trayvon Martin

(Continued from Part 1).

The State of Florida had to make the case that Mr George Zimmerman either bore the deceased Mr Trayvon Martin ill-will, or was depraved, and so sought to deliberately kill the child.

Over the five-week trial period, the State’s prosecuting attorney Bernie de la Rionda sought to make the case that Mr Zimmerman initiated the tragic events by purposefully stalking Mr Martin while carrying his loaded firearm. Further, Mr de la Rionda pressed that Mr Zimmerman could not plead justifiable self-defense if he instigated the incident. The prosecution, however, was unable to provide a witness that could directly refute Mr Zimmerman’s assertion that Mr Martin come out hiding in nearby bushes and attacked him.

Mr Zimmerman’s defense maintained that he had every right to discharge his weapon on Mr Martin, as at the point in question, he was being savagely attacked by the teenager. The defense’s position was the circumstances leading up to the altercation were immaterial. Further, Mr Zimmerman’s legal team made the surprising claim that Mr Martin had indeed been armed, using his fists and the sidewalk as assault weapons.

The six-person jury returned not-guilty verdicts on the charges of second-degree murder and manslaughter. This indicated that the prosecution’s case had been insufficient to convince the jurors beyond a reasonable doubt that Mr Zimmerman had acted willfully and maliciously in killing Mr Martin. Indeed, the local Sanford FL police and prosecutor had come to that conclusion soon after the tragic shooting in 2012, and thus had not initially charged Mr Zimmerman for the homicide.

Mr Zimmerman was thus freed and ‘no further business’ with court.

A few comments on ‘Stand Your Ground’ type laws. Natural law holds that one is justified in defending one’s life if one believes it is in imminent danger from another individual or individuals. However, I look to Police Departments’ standard procedure of putting officers involved in homicides on administrative leave, pending investigations of the killings. It is not clear to me what provisions Florida’s particular ‘Stand Your Ground’ statute make for investigating the circumstances of a ‘self-defense’ homicide.

What makes Mr Zimmerman’s case particularly irksome is the absence of witnesses to corroborate or contradict his version of events. In this absence, the local police authorities made the decision to believe Mr Zimmerman’s account, ultimately not holding him criminally liable for Mr Martin’s shooting death.

This is where I believe the Florida statute may be lacking.

This ‘Stand Your Ground’ law should be revised to automatically bring at least manslaughter charges in the event of a citizen using is as a defense for killing another person. The burden of proof should be on the shooter to justify his or her actions. However, this goes against the established principle of presumed innocence, where the prosecution has to make its case beyond a reasonable doubt. There is also the matter of the Constitution’s stance against forced self-incrimination.

As it stands now, the ‘Stand Your Ground’ law appears to allow for an individual to commit and be ultimately be held blameless for a homicide in circumstances where there are no witnesses or even corroborating evidence. That’s a troubling thought.

I look forward with great interest to the future Constitutional challenges to such laws. Because, while natural law condones the commission of a homicide in self-defense, it also cries out for an overwhelmingly reasonable justification for the extinguishing of another human life.

Marlon Johnson

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Print

Like this:

Like Loading...

On the State of Florida v George Zimmerman (2013): Part 1

Featured

Posted by marlonjohnson in Uncategorized

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Florida, George Zimmerman, Hoodie, Justice, Sanford FL, Stand Your Ground Law, Trayvon Martin

Much has been made of, especially in the conservative-leaning US media, that the case against Mr George Zimmerman was unmerited, and worse, politically motivated.
Indeed, I watched with great interest as Mr Geraldo Rivera, a Fox News commentator, remarked that, under Florida law, Mr Zimmerman committed no crime in killing Mr Trayvon Martin, a minor. Mr Zimmerman claimed that he had invoked his natural right to self-defense in shooting Mr Martin as an physical altercation between them became seriously violent. Florida state law allows for a citizen’s use of deadly force in the event he or she believes that his or her life is in immediate mortal danger from another individual.

Mr Zimmerman indicated that, while on neighborhood watch duty on the night in question, he had observed a suspicious looking individual traversing his community. He had reported the sighting to the police, and then exited his vehicle with his personal firearm to trail the individual. At some point soon after, an altercation between the two occurred, of which the details are still not clear. However, Mr Zimmerman admitted to having shot Mr Martin in the chest with his legal firearm.

The police collected statements from Mr Zimmerman, and of course, there were none forthcoming from the deceased Mr. Martin. The fact that Mr Martin had no weapon, and had been returning from a nearby store to his father’s house in Mr Zimmerman’s community, was noted with great alarm in the press.

Mr Rivera, the above mentioned commentator, reminded his viewers that the police and local prosecutor had declined to charge Mr Zimmerman in the immediate aftermath of the shooting, citing a lack of evidence on which to base a case.

Mr Rivera went on to posit that political pressure was put to bear on Florida’s State Prosecutor’s office, starting from the White House on down. He cited President Barack Obama’s comments in a March 2012 press appearance, in which the latter commented on the tragic case. Mr Rivera attempted to make the case that the President, by indirectly commenting on the deceased ethnicity, had essentially interfered with the course of justice, directly leading to the eventual arrest and charging of Mr Zimmerman with second degree murder.

With Mr Zimmerman now on trial, the State of Florida had to make the case that he either bore Mr Martin ill-will, or was depraved, and so sought to deliberately kill the child.

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Print

Like this:

Like Loading...

Subscribe

  • Entries (RSS)
  • Comments (RSS)

Archives

  • January 2015
  • May 2014
  • April 2014
  • March 2014
  • July 2013
  • May 2012
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • February 2011
  • January 2011

Categories

  • Caribbean Culture
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Jamaican Culture
  • Jamaican Politics
  • Media
  • Uncategorized

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in

Blog at WordPress.com.

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
%d bloggers like this: